ARGUMENTUM A SIMILI VALET IN LEGE Meaning and
Definition
-
"Argumentum a simili valet in lege" is a Latin legal term which translates to "an argument from a similar case is valid in law." This phrase encapsulates a legal principle that supports the notion that if a legal premise or conclusion has been established in a similar situation, it should be applicable and valid for a current case. It serves as a persuasive tool in legal reasoning, allowing lawyers and judges to draw parallels between cases and apply precedents to ensure fair and consistent outcomes.
The principle of "argumentum a simili valet in lege" forms the basis of legal precedent, which is the practice of using prior judgments as a guideline for similar cases. By referring to previous legal decisions with analogous circumstances, legal professionals can establish consistent interpretations of laws, ensure predictability in the legal system, and promote fairness and justice.
This principle can be employed during legal arguments and court proceedings to support a certain interpretation or legal outcome. Lawyers may rely on the facts, legal reasoning, and conclusions reached in previous cases to persuade the court to rule in favor of their client. Judges also utilize this principle when making decisions, relying on established legal principles and precedents to guide their judgment.
Overall, "argumentum a simili valet in lege" emphasizes the importance of consistency, fairness, and predictability in the application of the law by drawing upon analogous cases and their outcomes as persuasive evidence.
