NATURALISTIC FALLACY Meaning and
Definition
-
The naturalistic fallacy is a philosophical concept that refers to the mistaken belief that something being "natural" automatically makes it good, desirable, or ethically correct. This fallacy originated from the work of British philosopher G. E. Moore in the early 20th century. According to Moore, many people reasoned incorrectly by assuming that what is natural is inherently right or morally proper.
The fallacy arises when individuals attempt to derive moral judgments or values solely from natural facts or properties. It assumes that because something occurs naturally, it must be superior or preferable. This reasoning neglects the distinction between descriptive statements about the way things are and normative statements about how things ought to be. In other words, the naturalistic fallacy confuses facts with values.
Critics argue that this fallacy can lead to unsound reasoning and ethical dilemmas. It is important to consider that just because something is natural does not mean it is ethically sound or should be pursued. Similarly, just because something is unnatural does not automatically make it morally wrong or undesirable.
Understanding the naturalistic fallacy helps to foster critical thinking and ethical analysis by encouraging individuals to separate facts from values and to recognize that moral judgments require more than mere appeals to nature.
Etymology of NATURALISTIC FALLACY
The term "naturalistic fallacy" was introduced by British philosopher G. E. Moore in his 1903 book "Principia Ethica". The etymology of the term can be broken down as follows:
1. Naturalistic: Derived from the word "natural", which refers to the phenomena of the physical world and the laws that govern it. It implies something that is derived from or related to nature. In the context of the naturalistic fallacy, it pertains to the notion of deriving moral judgments from natural facts.
2. Fallacy: A term derived from the Latin word "fallacia", meaning deception or deceit. In logic, a fallacy refers to a mistaken or misleading argument or belief that is invalid or misleading.
Therefore, the etymology of the term "naturalistic fallacy" suggests the fallacy of deriving moral judgments or value statements from natural or descriptive facts.
