"Holds your water" is an idiomatic expression that refers to the ability of someone or something to withstand critical examination, scrutiny, or a challenging situation without losing credibility, validity, or effectiveness. It is often used figuratively to describe the strength, persuasiveness, or soundness of an argument, theory, or point of view when subjected to careful evaluation or skepticism.
When someone or something "holds your water," it means that they can convincingly support their stance or position, providing substantial and logical reasons, evidence, or explanations that can withstand scrutiny or debate. This expression highlights the ability to maintain credibility and consistently articulate or defend one's ideas even when faced with skepticism or criticism.
The concept of "holding water" metaphorically suggests that an argument or viewpoint is capable of functioning like a container that carries the weight or substance of rationality, coherence, and validity. Just as a container holds water without leaking or losing its contents, an argument or idea that "holds your water" possesses the ability to withstand challenges, doubts, or counterarguments without losing its persuasive power.
Therefore, when something "holds your water," it implies that it possesses the necessary qualities to remain tenable, defensible, or convincing, indicating a strong and unassailable position that endures under examination or skepticism, ensuring its continued validity or credibility.
